Manuscript Review - What's to Examine and How to Report Methodically !

Prof.(Dr.) D G Mahto, Founder & CEO -
Abstract:

Writing Involves:
Summarization, classification, analysis, critiques, and comparison.

The analysis, evaluation, and comparison require the use of theories, ideas, and research relevant to the subject area of the article.

It is also worth nothing if a review does not introduce new information, but instead presents a response to another writer's work.

Check out other samples to gain a better understanding of how to review the article.

Here are some tips for reviewing a journal article:
Read the abstract: The abstract summarizes the author's methodology and key findings. 
 
Consider the publication year: The latest research may be needed. 
 
Evaluate the organization: Consider how well the article's organization fits its purpose and key goals. 
 
Check the objectivity: Consider whether the author's argument is consistent and rational. 
 
Evaluate the presentation: Consider if the title is clear and appropriate, and if the author's statements are clear. 
 
Identify the main idea: Clarify the article's background, significance, and main idea. 
 
Summarize your review: Highlight the paper's strengths and weaknesses, and conclude with a summary of your main points. 
 
Recommend an action: Recommend whether the journal should accept the article as is, reject it, or ask for revisions. 
 
A journal article review is a professional paper that summarizes, analyzes, classifies, and compares literature on a topic. It should be a balanced discussion of the article's strengths and weaknesses. 

Conclusions 
How Many Publications Should You Review?
In what format should you cite your articles (MLA, APA, ASA, Chicago, etc.)?

What length should your review be?

Should you include a summary, critique, or personal opinion in your assignment?

Do you need to call attention to a theme or central idea within the articles?

Does your instructor require background information?

When you know the answers to these questions, you may start writing your assignment. 


Prof. (Dr.) D. G. Mahto is a multifaceted professional, serving as a Director, Professor, Philanthropist, HEI Builder, prolific writer, international consultant, reviewer, and expert career advisor at "Career Education for Success—Discover, Apply, Succeed!" He has guided countless individuals, products, and brands in discovering their true potential through insightful content, purposeful concepts, and motivational writing. With a deep sense of leadership and a commitment to community upliftment, he inspires others with his success stories and takes on the challenge of driving technological transformation, redefining social impact, and fostering interpersonal relationships for a more meaningful, balanced life. Prof. Mahto is dedicated to bridging the gap between dreams and reality for young people, striving for qualitative change in their lives. To explore his articles, books, and international journal contributions, visit his blogs at Career Education Success Now, Career Edus, and Discover Knowledge Wisely. You can also reach out to him via email.

Comments

Post a Comment

"Thank you for seeking advice on your career journey! Our team is dedicated to providing personalized guidance on education and success. Please share your specific questions or concerns, and we'll assist you in navigating the path to a fulfilling and successful career."